While I've never worn one out in the four years we've been full time, I've lost a couple because of my own neglect. They seem to fall off the pin when I unhook. When this happens, I forget to retrieve it and nature takes over and it blows out of the bed when I travel. I guess my mind isn't where it needs to be at times. If I could keep one long enough, I would replace it when it git thin enough to wear through. I would also try to keep it free of paint worn off of the hitch and debris to make it last longer. I've heard they can be attached with a countersunk screw but haven't seen that in person yet.