Are you suggesting that my automatic switch regulator is bad? If so How would I be able to check that? everything works as it should now after I replaced the 30 psi regulator. I think the system needs to have pressure to work and when the regulator went bad the system was unable to build pressure.
I'm saying that when it's time to fill an empty tank, you don't want to disconnect it and have propane flowing/leaking/spewing out of the disconnected pigtail. A working dual regulator that's set to the correct position won't allow that.
If you had a previous leak on one side, and it still leaked with the tank on that side shut off, the leak was coming from the full tank, through the dual regulator. Depending on how you had the dual regulator controls set, that may or may not have been normal.