I have one for you all!

hoefler

Well-known member
After having our Landmark in for an axle alignment and straightening, I was under the rig looking around at what they had done, I happened to notice an area sagging down behind the axles. I have always had a bulge there since we have owned it, 2 years now. I have tried pushing up on it in the past and had no movement. Thought it was normal. Well now it is really sagging and has pulled the skin down enough to be able to look inside. I can see the OSB that is under the fresh water tank. I cut the skin and proceed to get the water tank back up where it belongs. The 4" strap that ties the front and back support together has lost the pin that holds it in position, allowing the OSB to sag and pull out of the front and back cross supports. A terrible design by any standards!:rolleyes: You can not get a new piece of wood in place to support the tank with out cutting out the cross supports. Not going to cut anything out and try to weld it back together, too much to try and keep from burning up. I took a piece of Advantech OSB, highly moisture resistant and has a 50 year no seam swell warranty, cut it to size, then cut it in 2 width wise. Then I cut 3 pieces of 1 1/2" x 1 1/2" x 3/16" angle iron long enough to go from the front to the back cross supports and sit on top of them under the Advantech under the tank. Spot weld them in place to keep them from wiggling out.

Now here is the good part, while going about my repair, I noticed that there is 4 vents in this tank!!:confused: That is 4 of them, why?????:confused::confused: There is one in each corner, no wonder I couldn't keep any water in it. There is 3 that go from the right front, right rear, and left rear upper corners trough the skin and dump on the ground. There is one that goes to the gravity fill, this one I understand. But why is there 3 to the ground????:mad: We frequent parks with limited facilities and go to the races that have no facilities at all. We live in the Ozark mountains, nothing is flat and every where you go is uphill. It is no wonder we loose 2/3's of our water before we get anywhere.:mad:


I am going to remove 2 of the vents to the ground and installing a valve in the one I leave in. Now at least I can have a way to keep my water on-board instead of leaving a trail down the road!
 

jmgratz

Original Owners Club Member
After having our Landmark in for an axle alignment and straightening, I was under the rig looking around at what they had done, I happened to notice an area sagging down behind the axles. I have always had a bulge there since we have owned it, 2 years now. I have tried pushing up on it in the past and had no movement. Thought it was normal. Well now it is really sagging and has pulled the skin down enough to be able to look inside. I can see the OSB that is under the fresh water tank. I cut the skin and proceed to get the water tank back up where it belongs. The 4" strap that ties the front and back support together has lost the pin that holds it in position, allowing the OSB to sag and pull out of the front and back cross supports. A terrible design by any standards!:rolleyes: You can not get a new piece of wood in place to support the tank with out cutting out the cross supports. Not going to cut anything out and try to weld it back together, too much to try and keep from burning up. I took a piece of Advantech OSB, highly moisture resistant and has a 50 year no seam swell warranty, cut it to size, then cut it in 2 width wise. Then I cut 3 pieces of 1 1/2" x 1 1/2" x 3/16" angle iron long enough to go from the front to the back cross supports and sit on top of them under the Advantech under the tank. Spot weld them in place to keep them from wiggling out.

Now here is the good part, while going about my repair, I noticed that there is 4 vents in this tank!!:confused: That is 4 of them, why?????:confused::confused: There is one in each corner, no wonder I couldn't keep any water in it. There is 3 that go from the right front, right rear, and left rear upper corners trough the skin and dump on the ground. There is one that goes to the gravity fill, this one I understand. But why is there 3 to the ground????:mad: We frequent parks with limited facilities and go to the races that have no facilities at all. We live in the Ozark mountains, nothing is flat and every where you go is uphill. It is no wonder we loose 2/3's of our water before we get anywhere.:mad:


I am going to remove 2 of the vents to the ground and installing a valve in the one I leave in. Now at least I can have a way to keep my water on-board instead of leaving a trail down the road!

Your Landmark 'Classsic' is a whole different animal than the new ones. The original designs for the fresh water tanks was flawed (IMHO). Ours actually fell out when our unit was new. They (RV Capital) made some modifications to it and we have not had any more issues with it.
 

ChopperBill

Well-known member
I had the same problem on our "06" Bighorn. I fixed vents, sagging and not being able to fully empty the tanks. Here is a link to what I did. Water tank 101
 

Willym

Well-known member
I presume that multiple vents were installed so that the tank could be fully filled whatever the angle that the trailer may be at. This will work as long as each vent is routed up from the tank sufficiently before being looped back down to drain. The vents would also need to be of sufficient diameter so that a siphon could not start. The latter item was probably an issue. It would be better to route all vents upwards (no downward sections) and marry them with the main vent.

Did you take any photos of what you found, and the fix? My 2011 Rushmore FW tank also sags quite a bit and I have been considering additional support similar to what you seem to have done.
 

hoefler

Well-known member
Sorry, no pics. 3 of the vents all went down and terminated at the left rear corner of the tank. Any incline that you came upon would cause the water to run out. By eliminating 2 of them, both on the right side, and installing a valve in the remaining one on the left rear corner, it will stop any water lose going down the road and I still have one vent to the gravity fill that will take care of any expansion or venting from water use.

Another thing I forgot to mention earlier, for practical sense of the word insulated, the tank is not. There was no insulation around the tank. Nothing between the frame rails and the tank, and nothing between the cross members and the tank. Literally there was an air gap of 6"-8" between the frame and tank and 2"-3" between the tank and cross members and additional 4" to the bat insulation laying on top of the belly skin. Supply line to the pump was only an 1" above the skin and no insulation! Under the tank there was 3/4" OSB, 1 steal strap 4"x 48" x 1/16", paper thin fiberglass insulation of unknown value ( since it was compressed flat, it was useless anyways ), single layer bubble foil back radiant barrier, and the belly skin. No wonder that area of the floor was so cold!!

I stuffed R-30 Bat insulation on all sides of the tank to insulate it from all sides and help keep the heat in that radiates from above. Then after getting the tank properly supported, I used 1" blue high density styrene insulation to cover the bottom of the tank from frame rail to frame rail. This is the type of insulation they use in metal buildings under the steel siding. This seals off the entire underside of the tank, but I can not reinstall the belly skin and feel confident it will not blow off going down the road. But the foam insulation is tighter than the belly skin could ever think of being. Just a thought, may look into removing the flimsy plastic belly skin and replace it with the foam board insulation, tighter seal, better R value, won't sag, etc.. Hmmm!
 

Peteandsharon

Well-known member
ChopperBill,

I read your link above. I remember seeing it when you originally posted it. One question though. You refer to the "vent shut offs" and opening and closing them. I have no clue what you are talking about. Where do you open and close the vents?

Thanks

Pete
 

hoefler

Well-known member
Like my self, we installed the valves our self in the vent lines protruding out of the belly skin.
 

ChopperBill

Well-known member
ChopperBill,

I read your link above. I remember seeing it when you originally posted it. One question though. You refer to the "vent shut offs" and opening and closing them. I have no clue what you are talking about. Where do you open and close the vents?

Thanks

Pete

Yes on our "06" 3055 all three vents came out the bottom of the trailer. I put shut offs on all of them. Fill the tank when they are open and as you see one start of run water close it and wait for the next and so on. Insures you get a full tank and water will not siphon out as you go down the road. Out "011" apparently only has one vent to the filler as I can take a short hose and blow it our to insure the water is out to also get a full tanks.
 

Peteandsharon

Well-known member
OK. Maybe I'm still confused and need to look at this again. The only thing that comes out of the bottom of my rig related to freshwater is the freshwater tank drain. It obviously has an on-off valve. Outside of that, I have nothing draining through the belly in my '08 BH 3055. I don't see any signs of air vents.
 
Top