My reason for asking is that I have had both. Back in 2005, when I joined this forum I had a Bighorn. It had a few problems, got them straightened out, wasn't a unit. I since have moved on to another product, a Cameo, a Carriage product no longer in business. Tom Montague (Hi Tom), who I have known for a long time used to work there. He is familiar with the vinyl roof. I have just retired from the RV industry after being involved for 36 years. While working with at the dealership, we replaced many rubber roofs, not one TPO Vinyl roof. With my own experience, I have found it a lot more durable and easier to take care of. easier to clean, no need to use conditioner, doesn't tear easily. Anyway, I am in the market to move on to a new unit. While browsing, I looked at the Landmark. Has some nice floorplans, and some good features. It has now been added to the list, now three, of products one of which I will buy. Landmark has the best price point of what I am looking at. For me, at this point of RVing, price isn't the issue, construction is; frame, materials used, roof, etc.