Any of them are only as good as your visibility of the southern sky satellite arc. If you're camping in a cow pasture, probably any one will work. In the northern woods, good luck. The further north, the lower the arc is to the horizon. Put some tall trees in there and a fly on a leaf will block the signal. We had DISH for a couple of seasons, but dropped it and put the gear in storage after some of the oak trees to the south of our summer site (off the CG property) grew taller and leafier.
Since there were only a couple of summer programs we watched, I just stream them the next day via our MiFi through my laptop to the TV. Any others are recorded on DVR to watch when we get home. Other than the PBS channels, the other OTA channels pixelate to frustration.
And when shopping for satellite service, don't be overwhelmed by the number of channels they offer. "250 channels" means most of it is reruns, kiddy shows, music channels, foreign language, or holy-roller proselytizing. And the major network channels, HBO, Cinemax, etc., may come at a premium, if at all.
We don't miss it.