I had an issue with my 2011 Elkridge 5th wheel. The roof had water damage in the rear corner where the ladder was mounted. I weighed the costs:
1.) Replace and repair roof $3200 (replace rotted wood and rubber on 1/2 of roof).
2.) Replace rotted wood and replace entire rubber roof $4500.
3.) Remove rubber and replace rotted wood with treated plywood, Prep and spray a new roof on $5100...
I opted for number 3.
It is a spray on roof process similar to a bedliner. Has the same UV ratings as most spray in liners. will not fade.
No Maintenance, No caulking everything is sealed. It is a very clean job and was professionally done in the Baltimore area.
It has a 20 year leak free warranty.
The wood that was replaced was NOT the OSB type that was there but was treated plywood. It was a 20"x20" repair.
The leak was found in the area of the trim piece at the roof/rear wall area. There had been an eternabond tape repair, probably by the dealer where a tree limb most likely fell and tore the rubber. However, when they replaced the trim piece the ran a screw right thru the eternabond.
OSB is like a sponge and soaked the water up like a sponge.
This roof replacement is newer to the market, and while expensive, with the warranty it seems worth it. I do know that it is lighter then the rubber roofing material so there is no additional weight. The only weight increase was the replacement plywood but at the size area that was replaced it is minimal.