Not sure if you have fixed your problem yet but I just went through the same issue. While the 4 way selector was in the city position, water was going into the fresh water tank. (I can hear the water movement at the 4 way selector valve.) This was after I noticed water dumping from the overflow tube of the fresh water tank. I immediately turned the water supply off and drain the fresh water tank down. In doing so, with the selector valve was in the normal position, the pump worked fine. The pump was holding pressure so I ruled out the check valve on the pump. I called Heartland customer service and after discussing this with them, they too decided it was the 4 way selector valve. They shipped me one and we are back in business. Hope this helps you.