Well 18 posts and pretty much all agree that the Timbrens are the ticket, then comes the 19th. So I was all set to pull the trigger, now I'm not so sure, i've used the ride rite airbags with great success, but, they are expensive and a pain to install. Now I guess I'll have to do some soul searching and make a command decision.
I have had a number of pickups with Firestone Air Bags and also with Timbrens. They both were used with campers and also a Montana 5th (just ordered a Bighorn).
The air bags were a nuisance as air loss developed over time, sometimes faster than you think and maybe dirt and rough roads aggrevated that compression fitting they use. Same experience on two trucks and air bag maintenance, installed by different dealers. The expected life of the Air Bag according to one installing dealer was 5 years.
Regarding ride, they are required to have some air in them when unloaded, so there is still a rougher ride empty than with no air bags. In the colder climes where I live, the pressure unloaded has to be adjusted and the stiffness of the unloaded air bag in cold sure changes.
The Timbrens on severe bumps do bottom and are like hitting the overload on bumps. The air bags change the rebound on a bump too, there is more stiffness through out their entire motion empty so it is different.
So far:
2 trucks with air bags (2003 Duramax and 2008 Dodge that had one air bag fail and replaced under waranty, then I took them off and got Timbrens).
3 with Timbrens (2 of those were Dodges 2004 and 2008 w/Cummins).
All trucks have RV'd over the Alaska highway many times, so they all got a work out.
When I pick up the new BH 3055, using a F350 SRW and if it is not level, I prefer Timbrens.
I dislike the filling (exact poundage is not always easy and changes with temperatures, leaking, cold stiffness and plumbing.
Timbrens are very easy to install and not quite as much cost as air bags, but the little difference in cost should not be the deciding factor. Each to their own and lots of opinions and configurations.
Just no maintenance and when empty, ride return to normal so for me after using both on a couple of trucks, Timbrens get my vote.