I put a tankless unit in our Cyclone. Eh. Overall I like the original unit better. I think HL would have to work really hard to have a tankless setup that the customer feels works "well".
It's nice to have hot water "right now" in that you don't have to wait for the tank to heat up.
The tankless unit we have is definitely fussy. If you don't use the shower in a particular way, it will hit you with cold water. The original WH worked like your house and you don't have to think about how you are using it. The exception was when you just set up camp and have to wait for the water to heat up, or if you are dry camping and didn't have the tank turned on to save propane during the day. The tankless works nice for conserving propane for dry camping.
Dry camping example:
Want hot shower when done for the day, great the tankless will give you hot water without waiting for the 5+ gallons in a tank to heat up, so you save time and propane.
You want to conserve water, so shut off the shower between actions (ie no water when soaping up or however you do it). That's great, except the tankless it going to hit you with cold for x seconds when you turn the water back on. The only way, with our unit, to keep a consistent temp out of the shower is to keep it spraying the whole time. So, save on propane but lose on water.
If HL could give a tankless setup that worked as consistent and as easily as the traditional tank, I'd be interested.
It's nice to have hot water "right now" in that you don't have to wait for the tank to heat up.
The tankless unit we have is definitely fussy. If you don't use the shower in a particular way, it will hit you with cold water. The original WH worked like your house and you don't have to think about how you are using it. The exception was when you just set up camp and have to wait for the water to heat up, or if you are dry camping and didn't have the tank turned on to save propane during the day. The tankless works nice for conserving propane for dry camping.
Dry camping example:
Want hot shower when done for the day, great the tankless will give you hot water without waiting for the 5+ gallons in a tank to heat up, so you save time and propane.
You want to conserve water, so shut off the shower between actions (ie no water when soaping up or however you do it). That's great, except the tankless it going to hit you with cold for x seconds when you turn the water back on. The only way, with our unit, to keep a consistent temp out of the shower is to keep it spraying the whole time. So, save on propane but lose on water.
If HL could give a tankless setup that worked as consistent and as easily as the traditional tank, I'd be interested.