Hi,
Traverler44, You are correct about the differences in cast iron. The quality of cast iron is different and it does affect the wear of the drum. Technically speaking the cast rion drum or rotor shoud wear less than the pads because the pads are designed to be softer than the surface that they rub against. However some manufacturers of pad material don't care about that. Sometime they will give a lifetime warranty for their pads/shoes. They know they are harder and the rotor/drum will wear before their stuff wears and since their brake material is still good you buy new rotors or drums. That's not how it's supposed to work. The drum/rotor will wear but it's not supposed to wear more than the brake material. What can you do???? My suggestion is to go to NAPA when and if you have to purchase drums/rotors. As I told my students. The smaller parts stores don't have a National reputation to deal with, NAPA does. Dealers will sell you for the most part OEM (original equipment manufacturer) specifications stuff. That should mean that it is as good as the original. Parts houses don't do that. They will often have 2-5 price ranges and that will determine the warranty and the quality. If you walk into a parts store to buy they don't want you walking out. If they hit you with a price if it is to much they will hit you with a cheaper price. It's been a few years but prices for disc pads might vary from $20 to $60 for the same application. What's the difference??? Quality, quality, quality. When it comes to brake material I ask of OEM or better at the NAPA store. They above all others seemed to keep up with the quality aspect. I'm sure their are others stores but since I used NAPA I didn't look beyond. There is also a vast difference in the quality of cast iron. The differences in rotors would boggle your mind. you don't have to worry just ask for a rotor that meet or exceedes OEM specs and they will provide it for you. It may not be cheap but it should and will be the best they can offer. I'll close by telling you one more story. I ordered an exhaust for a vehicle years ago. I went in to pick it up and it was slightly different and would not work. When they found the correct one the difference in weight was at least double. I asked why and they told me that the first one was to OEM specs and was considerable thicker. The other one was not and was a lot thinner. The average person would not know the difference but you can bet the the thinner exhaust would not last nearly as long as the other. That's when I realized that parts houses do manufacturer parts that are less than OEM specs. It's all about the bottom line. When it comes to brakes I want the best and I'll pay what ever I have to to get it. As far as I am concerned the dealers offer quality and so does NAPA. At the dealer you are also paying for the name. No I don't own stock in NAPA.
TeJay